Lost Among the Living
by Simone St. James
GENRE: #GothicMysteryRomance #ParanormalMystery #HalloweenRead
π
Setting: England | ⏳
Era: Post-World War I (1921)
My rating: ★★★★★
5 FULL STARS WELL DESERVED!! :-D
Wow! Can I just say
I loved it?
I had been planning to read this around Halloween or November for a whole year—ever since I read another mystery with a strong romantic undertone by this same talented writer.
And I wasn't disappointed one bit!
Paranormal mysteries aren't usually my cup of tea—I'd say I normally avoid them—but autumn is the perfect time to indulge in something that really keeps the suspense high and sends a shiver down your spine. There's nothing quite like a ghost, an isolated house near the woods, and people hiding dark secrets to give you goosebumps. Yet the real delight is that, despite all the gloom and anguish gripping both the protagonist and us readers, love always leads to truth and salvation—and Simone St. James always delivers happy endings for all the good people in the story.
π THE PLOT IN A NUTSHELL:
England, 1921. It has been three agonizing years since Jo Manders lost her husband, Alex, whose plane was shot down over enemy skies in Germany. Bound by necessity, Jo now serves as a paid companion to Alex’s haughty and wealthy aunt, Dottie Forsyth, a role that brings her to the sprawling, isolated family estate in Sussex. Yet, beneath the manor’s grand facade lies a web of hidden truths about Alex’s past—starting with the unearthing of a suspicious, long-buried death that hints at dark family secrets.
Trouble clings to the walls of Wych Elm House like a shroud. Dottie’s husband remains emotionally unreachable, while their son bears the devastating physical consequences of the wounds of the Great War. Within the mansion, the atmosphere grows increasingly unsettling: phantom footsteps echo down vacant corridors, and personal belongings are mysteriously shifted while Jo sleeps. Whispering villagers claim the Forsyth bloodline is blighted by a curse, tied to a restless spirit that haunts the surrounding woods.
As Jo uncovers the chilling truths of her late husband’s hidden life, she is forced to confront a terrifying question: Did she ever truly know the man she married? Trapped in a stronghold of sorrow and deceit, she must unravel the truth before it consumes her entirely.
Then, a familiar stranger crosses the threshold of Wych Elm House, and everything changes…
π MY THOUGHTS
The story is told in the first person by Jo Manders, and even though there are many chapters with very little dialogue—where she walks us through her present and her past—there wasn't a single moment where I felt bored. Curiosity and suspense are constantly there, because every event, even the most seemingly innocent one, feels slightly off, as if something doesn't quite add up and there is always a hidden motive lurking behind another…
| π A WELL-DRAWN MAIN CHARACTER:
Joanna (Jo) Manders: a tenacious and determined protagonist.
Although you might initially think she's a fragile young woman, weighed down by grief and her job as a companion to a domineering woman, chapter after chapter we discover how life forced her to fend for herself from an early age. We see how her
determination and desire to uncover the truth are stronger than any fear or threat, and stronger even than choosing an easier, more convenient path.
Beyond her
strength of spirit and tenacity, I truly appreciated her
self-respect in shutting down Uncle Robert's veiled advances and contemptuous remarks, as well as her pride in refusing to be pitied by either the lawyer or the colonel. I loved her pride in not giving in to her deepest desires after feeling betrayed—first by lies, then by half-truths—by the very person she trusted most.
I deeply admire her
determination to stay independent without relying on anyone.
I found her to be an amazing heroine because, on top of all this, she shows genuine
empathy toward those who are suffering (like Dottie's son, a war veteran dealing with painful physical wounds; his little sister Frances, trapped between one world and another; or Jo's own mother, struggling with mental illness). Jo never judges—she understands—and her
intelligence and intuition complete the portrait of a capable heroine whom I rooted for from start to finish.
| π SIDE CHARACTERS:
The
novel focuses primarily on Jo and the vaguely gothic atmosphere shaped by past events haunting the present, so the
secondary characters might seem sketched with lighter strokes at first. However, as the story unfolds, their actions speak volumes about who they really are.
Through just a few traits and snippets of dialogue, through fleeting glances and tones of voice,
we get a crystal-clear picture of each of them.
- Alex, the mysterious, handsome, and passionate husband who vanished into thin air—and who might be a hero, a spy, or even a murderer.
- Dottie, the cold and calculating aunt, completely devoid of empathy, who has her own rigid plans for her son.
- Martin, Dottie and Robert's son, now a frail war veteran battling an addiction and hovering close to death, yet a loyal friend to Jo.
- Cora, his fiancΓ©e, who comes across as a bit naive at first, though deep down she is far more down-to-earth and capable than she appears.
- Robert, the treacherous, unfaithful husband who cares about nothing and no one except himself.
- Frances, the little girl who saw the dead and now cannot rest in peace.
- Wilde, the crippled lawyer disliked by the entire village.
- Colonel Mabry, an ambiguous man who clearly knows much more than he lets on.
The
cast is rich and multifaceted, and just like in a classic detective novel,
each character drops small pieces of the puzzle that we readers get to gather alongside Jo to piece together the truth.
| ππ DARKNESS AND LIGHT, MYSTERY AND ROMANCE EXPERTLY BALANCED:
As I mentioned, I'm not usually a fan of the paranormal—I often find it too unsettling—but
this author's stories always carry a tender, sweet side. In this book, Jo also shares the story of her romance with her husband before he went missing in action.
The hardships Jo faces at this point in her life—the
coldness surrounding her, the chills of a little girl's ghostly apparitions, wet leaves appearing in her bed, and the eerie howl of the wind through the trees—are
skillfully balanced by her memories of meeting Alex, their instant spark and connection, and their longing for a love that binds them deeply, intensely, and forever.
Two contrasting moods are seamlessly woven together by the author, making everything feel
real and believable in every aspect, without ever tipping into the ridiculous.
- The mystery is cleverly constructed, the clues fit together seamlessly, and the story flows smoothly—always keeping the right level of tension while revealing just enough to spark new questions and keep you turning the pages.
- I always like to play detective as I read and guess who did what and why. Sometimes I figure it out early, but I have to admit I didn't guess who the real culprit was until right before the author revealed it.
- The love story was sweet in Jo's memories and became poignant and sensual in the present—even without any explicit scenes—so I thoroughly enjoyed this side of the book as well.
| π A SATISFYING ENDING:
There is
nothing better than an ending where the villains get what they deserve and things turn out right for the good ones.
It was a deeply satisfying conclusion that gave closure to the characters I cared about and
tied up all the loose ends across the various storylines.
One thing I really loved was having
three full chapters dedicated to the ending, offering a genuine
glimpse into the characters' future lives.
My only tiny complaint is that
the villain's punishment felt "too quick": I would have loved to read and savor at least three whole pages watching that person suffer humiliation and pay for what they did (do you think that sounds a little ruthless of me? Trust me, once you read the book, you'll completely understand my thirst for justice after all those crimes!). Instead, I had to settle for finding out their fate in just a few sentences.
| ⏳ HISTORICAL CONNECTIONS & TIMELESS THEMES:
Beyond the mystery of unsolved deaths and disappearances, the
book offers plenty of food for thought on the condition of war veterans and women in society—themes we might assume belong to the past, yet remain strikingly relevant today.
The author highlights how soldiers returning from the front needed not only physical healing, but also emotional support, comfort, and a new purpose to start living again.
Through Jo's eyes, we clearly see how few opportunities widowed women and single mothers had back then, and how quickly they were judged or ostracized at the slightest hint of independence or modern thinking.
Mental illness was treated as a shameful stigma, just like physical disabilities; married women weren't allowed to work; marriage was often little more than a contract arranged by parents…
We have certainly come a long way in fighting for change, yet even today, in our modern world, war veterans still struggle to reintegrate into society and often fall into devastating addictions while battling physical and invisible wounds. Likewise, women
still face social prejudice, and even on a practical and professional level, there are still plenty of hurdles left to overcome.
I love it when a novel,
beyond pure entertainment, gives you something meaningful to reflect on and discuss—it adds so much depth to the reading experience.
| ππ» WOULD I RECOMMEND IT?
Yes, wholeheartedly! The
writing is clear and accessible, the
plot flows effortlessly, the mystery is packed with clues that
keep the suspense alive, and the touch of
romance is genuinely heartwarming.
It's an
engaging mystery suitable for everyone, and I especially recommend it to readers like me who steer clear of gory thrillers but love a cozy, mildly gothic atmosphere.
Thank you so much for stopping by and reading my thoughts!
With love,
Tiziπ½πΎπΎ
Join me on FACEBOOK: Tizi Cozy Corner
to stay updated on my latest reviews and bookish news! ✨
FOLLOW ME or SEND ME A FRIEND REQUEST ON GOODREADS